PROJECT
Worth 60% of final gradeFormat
An individual or group research project of a self-contained idea in visualization. Milestones (and deliverables) for the project:
-
Due 23 Jan.
Project proposal -
Due 13 Feb.
Mid-term evaluation -
Due 3 Apr.
Final presentation -
Due
3 Apr. 15 April
Project report
Note that a research contribution is not equal to engineering: the methodology employed, the originality of the research and technical soundness of the work are most important. A well-crafted application will not be a subsitute for research quality and contribution. Moreover, while projects generally include the development of an interactive visualization application, in-depth qualitative studies (with rich discussion on implications for visualization design) are also suitable for this assignment [see for instance Active Reading in Visualization, and Useful Junk?]. Similarly to a project involving developement, the methodology, originality and technical soundness of the work will be evaluated.
Grading
The project contributes 60% of the final grade.
The following break-down will be used for marking:
• Project proposal (2 of the 60)
• Mid-term evaluation (10 of the 60)
• Project report (20 of the 60)
• Final presentation (10 of the 60)
• Project execution (18 of the 60)
How are presentations graded? See the presentation evaluation grid.
How is the project report graded?: The overall exposition of the research will be evaluated: work motivation, technical soundness, related work, clarity, results and perspectives. Presentation and writing quality are important.
What is the project execution grade? The originality and quality of the research contribution and execution (i.e. methodology, design process, implementation, evaluation, ...).
Project proposal
Description
A meaningful title and summary (max 700 words) describing your project.
The summary (max 700 words) can be seen as a preliminary draft of the introduction of the research paper (project report) that you will submit at the end of the term. It should describe the topic of your project (motivation, e.g., why it is important, why it is difficult) and the research question that you are trying to address, possibly a brief positionning (what has been done in the area, and why these prior works are limited; what are prior works you bear inspiration from and why), and a description of your envisionned solution.
Please also attach a short biography (a few words about you and why you take this class), as well as a portrait photograph (headshot) of yourself.
Submission instructions
Due on 23 Jan., no later than 11:59pm.Send your submission as a document (Word document or PDF) by email with the object "[CSC2537/STA2555] Project proposal submission of [list all group members' name]". Make sure that you cc' all of your group members.
Mid-term presentation
Description
A lightning talk (<5min) of current state of the project.
As for the project summary, the presentation should cover the following aspects: topic of your project; what is the research question that you are trying to address? why is it important? positioning (i.e. brief overview of prior works), and your envisionned solution..
Deliverable
Presentations on 13 Feb., during the class.Presentations will be recorded for internal use only. You don't have any other deliverable besides giving the talk in class.
Project report
Description
The project report should be seen as a research paper submission, short format (4-6 pages, references do not count toward page limit). As such, it should include all of the components of a reaserach paper (strong motivation, positioning, clear statement of the reseach question and contribution, ...). All of the papers presented in class are good example of good quality research papers (if you have not read them yet, do so!).
Deliverable
Due on. Submit a 4 to 6 pages paper at the CHI Proceeding Format (templates: LaTeX, Word). Please name your pdf: "[name(s)]-projectreport.pdf"
Note: If you believe you will need to go over the 6-page limit, check with Haijun whether it is justified to do so. Explain the reasons why 6-page will not be sufficient, and he'll give you clearance where appropriate, or help you identify parts of document that may be timmed down. Submission: Send your pdf by email, with the following object: "[CSC2537-STA2555] Project report of [your name(s)]" to both haijunxia[at]dgp.toronto.edu and fanny[at]cs.toronto.edu.
Final presentation
Description
The final presentation (15min) should mostly focus on the work you have realized, your research contribution (i.e., field study, formative study, design rationales, demo/description of the solution, evaluation, ...). Intro / motivation / related work, while worth including, should remain concise (between 2-5min).
Deliverable
Presentations on 3 Apr., 3 sessions (9am-11am; 12pm-2pm; 2pm-4pm).20 min total for each project: 15min presentation + 5min questions.
Schedule
Last updated on March 22.
-
27 March 2018
- 10:20am Suzan & Joey
- 10:20am Vivek & Niel
-
3 April 2018 (9AM-11AM)
- 9:10am Yu Ting
- 9:30am Vincent & Christine
- 9:50am Alexandra
- 10:10am Lily
- 10:30am Catherine & Fahime
-
3 April 2018 (12PM-2PM)
- 12:00pm Bryon
- 12:20pm Lebo
- 12:40pm Charles-Olivier
- 1:00pm Coby
- 1:20pm Mickaƫl
- 1:40pm Ioannis
-
3 April 2018 (2PM-4PM)
- 2:10pm Nicholas
- 2:30pm Kasra
- 2:50pm Benett
- 3:10pm Zain
- 3:30pm Alexandre